Page 1 of 2

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 12:25 am
by Lansky1
OLDE CUTLER wrote:Those of you who mentioned that the Lansky is not perfect are all correct. But for the bulk of pocket knife sharpening it works good enough. The very largest blades are a problem as are the very smallest. This topic is suffering from a lack of pictures to show different setups, so I spent some time to try to get something to show. Not that easy to get things setup to see the angles.
If you put the blade clamp on in different places, this will affect the angle somewhat. As shown below, if the clamp is too far back toward the handle, more metal seems to be ground unnecessarily from the tip. Shown on a Buck 110 for example
IMG_2533.JPG
I usually put the clamp on more toward the center or even more towards the tip to avoid this.
IMG_2534.JPG
When sharpening small pen blades, the stones can actually rub on the clamp, so I don't use the clamp for small blades. I hold the knife as shown with the hand resting on the table and using just the Lansky stone (fine diamond shown) without the guide rod, with the bottom end resting on the table. I try to approximate 25 degrees blade to stone angle while doing this. Just rock the top end of the stone back and forth towards and away from the tip.
IMG_2535.JPG
Turn over and do the other side.
IMG_2536.JPG
Small pen blades usually don't need that much to sharpen, and this method has worked for me.
Great tips - I mount the clamp on a clip blade in about the same spot as you do. I like your idea about sharpening little blades with Lansky stones freehand - I will most def try that. ::tu::

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 12:35 am
by ken98k
I've got one but don't care for it at all ::barf::
Nowadays I used a flat ceramic or ceramic rod almost exclusively. ::tu::

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 5:25 pm
by Lansky1
ken98k wrote:I've got one but don't care for it at all ::barf::
just curious ... why don't you care for it ? I'm aware some feel it takes too much time to set up & they feel it isn't worth the hassle. Some would rather just grab an oil stone and have at it ? Thing is, I've never heard of anyone who learned to use the Lansky and didn't get better results than freehand sharpening. Don't get the wrong impression - I'm not grilling you, I'm just curious what you didn't like about the Lansky ... thx ::tu::

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Thu Nov 22, 2018 6:53 am
by ken98k
Lansky1 wrote:
ken98k wrote:I've got one but don't care for it at all ::barf::
just curious ... why don't you care for it ? I'm aware some feel it takes too much time to set up & they feel it isn't worth the hassle. Some would rather just grab an oil stone and have at it ? Thing is, I've never heard of anyone who learned to use the Lansky and didn't get better results than freehand sharpening. Don't get the wrong impression - I'm not grilling you, I'm just curious what you didn't like about the Lansky ... thx ::tu::
Like you said, takes too much time.

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Fri Nov 23, 2018 6:06 pm
by cbnutt
To me the main problem has been small wore down blades that I cant get the stone to touch because it hits the clamp first , on large blades , say like a buck 110 or something , it kind of runs out of stone about halfway through the blade , I guess on that you just kind of start over at that point , and use two strokes on the blade to get the full length covered .

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Fri Nov 23, 2018 10:30 pm
by Colonel26
ken98k wrote:
Lansky1 wrote:
ken98k wrote:I've got one but don't care for it at all ::barf::
just curious ... why don't you care for it ? I'm aware some feel it takes too much time to set up & they feel it isn't worth the hassle. Some would rather just grab an oil stone and have at it ? Thing is, I've never heard of anyone who learned to use the Lansky and didn't get better results than freehand sharpening. Don't get the wrong impression - I'm not grilling you, I'm just curious what you didn't like about the Lansky ... thx ::tu::
Like you said, takes too much time.
I agree Ken. That and the fact that I like to put a nice long low angle bevel on mine and then a bit steeper secondary bevel. That clamp just gets in my way. If I want a 30° angle I’ll just use an ax.

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2018 4:24 am
by Lansky1
Colonel26 wrote:I agree Ken. That and the fact that I like to put a nice long low angle bevel on mine and then a bit steeper secondary bevel. That clamp just gets in my way. If I want a 30° angle I’ll just use an ax.
It's all comes down to preference - I can get an absolutely scary sharp perfectly formed edge using the 30 degree setting on the Lansky running through the various diamond stones ... I've never needed to go any lower & can't imagine anyone would need a knife any sharper. One thing that hasn't been mentioned yet is the 30 degree edge is much more durable than a steeper angle - it holds up better & lasts longer between sharpenings. We're getting into preferences, which isn't the intent of this thread, so ::handshake:: ...

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2018 4:33 am
by Lansky1
cbnutt wrote:To me the main problem has been small wore down blades that I cant get the stone to touch because it hits the clamp first , on large blades , say like a buck 110 or something , it kind of runs out of stone about halfway through the blade , I guess on that you just kind of start over at that point , and use two strokes on the blade to get the full length covered .
FYI ... I've learned over time to take about 5-8 strokes per side - seems to work best ... don't have to get the whole length of the blade in one swipe like you might with a full size oil stone.

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2018 2:50 am
by UnderDawgAl
I use the Smith-branded sharpening system, which is basically a poor man's Lansky. It has both the strengths and weaknesses of the Lansky as outlined above. The Smith that I have only gives you two angle choices--20 and 25 degrees.

I find the greatest strength of this type of system is its ability to quickly show you how even or uneven the factory edge is. Here's how: When you first start sharpening a blade with one of the included stones or diamond-grit bars, you can run your finger tip across the blade at all points to see if you're creating a wire edge consistently along the whole length of the blade. Often, I've found that one or more spots on the blade don't roll the wire edge over to the opposite side of the blade. That tells me I need to spend some time on those spots until a wire edge forms. At that point, I can then proceed with normal sharpening. This has primarily been necessary for me.on stainless steel blades.

My system has just two diamond-grit bars, with the coarse being around 350 grit and the fine being 600 grit.
I wanted a keener edge, so I bought sandpaper in grits of 1K, 1.5K, 2K, 3K, 5K, and 7K. I didnt buy all those at once but acquired them over a few months. I then cut a piece of sandpaper of each grit just large enough to wrap.around the sharpening bar. That way, I can maintain the same angle and hone each blade going up to 7000 grit.

After a few months of enjoying the satisfaction of getting the blades so sharp, i began to just sharpen to whatever grit I feel like, based on time constraints and the number of times my young kids interrupt me.

For the blades that are too small for the clamp, I worked on developing and improving my free hand technique.

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Fri Dec 07, 2018 7:17 pm
by cbnutt
Liking mine so far , I may need to get some diamond stones for it .

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2018 2:29 am
by sparkyv
Lansky1 wrote:I’ll start ....

- put a little piece of blue painters tape on the top edge of the knife where it mounts in the jig to prevent those annoying tell tale Lansky scratches.

- watch the inside of your right hand - if you slip, the blade tip is very close to the inside of your wrist

- I have tried all 4 sharpening angles & have settled on using the top hole (30 degrees). It seems to work perfectly for all of my slip joints ... and the best part is I always know which angle to use regardless of what knife I’m re-sharpening

- the standard stones dish out from wear over time - but the diamond stones always stay flat as the diamond sharpening media is bonded to a steel plate. It’s worth it to me to pony up for the diamond set

- I’ve Found the single most important part of the Lansky system is to buy the mounting base so it’s stable - trying to freehand that Lansky clamp is actually quite dangerous.

Much wisdom from Lansky1. I upgraded to the diamond stones, and they took this tool to a whole new level. I just sharpen until I feel the burr, flip, repeat, do this once again, and then move to the next stone and do the same. Then I finish with stropping to get rid of any remaining burr. I have settled on the 25° setting, and it works pretty well for me, but I may try the 30° to see how that performs. One other thing I do; the hole the rod goes through has a lot of slop, so I place my finger over (under is ok, too) the rod, behind the hole to reduce the slop. Taught my son to use it; didn't take him long to get excellent results. ::tu::

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2018 3:43 am
by Lansky1
sparkyv wrote:
Lansky1 wrote:I’ll start ....

- put a little piece of blue painters tape on the top edge of the knife where it mounts in the jig to prevent those annoying tell tale Lansky scratches.

- watch the inside of your right hand - if you slip, the blade tip is very close to the inside of your wrist

- I have tried all 4 sharpening angles & have settled on using the top hole (30 degrees). It seems to work perfectly for all of my slip joints ... and the best part is I always know which angle to use regardless of what knife I’m re-sharpening

- the standard stones dish out from wear over time - but the diamond stones always stay flat as the diamond sharpening media is bonded to a steel plate. It’s worth it to me to pony up for the diamond set

- I’ve Found the single most important part of the Lansky system is to buy the mounting base so it’s stable - trying to freehand that Lansky clamp is actually quite dangerous.

Much wisdom from Lansky1. I upgraded to the diamond stones, and they took this tool to a whole new level. I just sharpen until I feel the burr, flip, repeat, do this once again, and then move to the next stone and do the same. Then I finish with stropping to get rid of any remaining burr. I have settled on the 25° setting, and it works pretty well for me, but I may try the 30° to see how that performs. One other thing I do; the hole the rod goes through has a lot of slop, so I place my finger over (under is ok, too) the rod, behind the hole to reduce the slop. Taught my son to use it; didn't take him long to get excellent results. ::tu::
Nice - glad you like the Lansky. Agree - it's such an easy system to use, doesn't take much experience with it to get excellent results. ::handshake::

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Mon Dec 30, 2019 4:12 pm
by Lansky1
I learned something recently when sharpening the very fine point of a wharncliffe. Sometimes, the very tip gets slightly off the line of the rest of the straight edge blade and if you look close, it reflects poorly on the quality of the grind. What I learned when forming the fine tip, is that I now do NOT let the edge of the stone go past the tip of the blade. Sometimes, you can go about halfway out on the stone without feeling like you're losing control of it, but you do lose the guidance the entire face of the stone provides when on the blade, and it goes slightly off straight. Don't let the edge of the stone go past the tip, and your tip grinds will be perfect.

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Mon Dec 30, 2019 4:52 pm
by jerryd6818
This is my set-up.

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 1:09 pm
by fergusontd
::tu:: I use this Lansky, I find it just great .I don't care for scary sharp just sharp enough to slice paper with my 301 Buck and my Case Trapper lock. ftd
SmartSelect_20191231-080511_Chrome.jpg
SmartSelect_20191231-080511_Chrome.jpg (12.98 KiB) Viewed 9481 times

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Sun Jan 05, 2020 3:21 am
by Lansky1
jerryd6818 wrote: Mon Dec 30, 2019 4:52 pm This is my set-up.
Very nice organized set up Jerry - I like what you did there. My setup is basically a stationary drill press table with the Lansky C-clamp mount but the whole area is disorganized and gets messy with oil - I like yours a whole lot better ! ::tu::

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2021 9:41 pm
by Mark in PA
I've been using a Gatco for several years. Looks very similar to the Lansky. I just purchased one of these from Amazon. Anxious for it to arrive and see how well it works.

https://www.amazon.com/Work-Sharp-Preci ... den&sr=1-1

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2021 10:40 pm
by OLDE CUTLER
I am interested in hearing your report on how this sharpener works. Especially on large blades and small blades which can be a problem for the Lansky.

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2021 12:13 am
by cudgee
Mark in PA wrote: Sun Jan 31, 2021 9:41 pm I've been using a Gatco for several years. Looks very similar to the Lansky. I just purchased one of these from Amazon. Anxious for it to arrive and see how well it works.

https://www.amazon.com/Work-Sharp-Preci ... den&sr=1-1
Make sure that you give us a full report when you have used it, looks good and has some good reviews. But always like reviews on AAPK much better, they are always more accurate. But i do like the look of your purchase, well done. ::tu:: ::nod:: ::handshake::

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2021 3:51 am
by old4570
Tips ? ::hmm::

Marker Pen ..
Mark the bevel / cutting edge ..
?????????? Do you want to match the edge ?
How badly damaged / used / rounded is the edge . ( I have seen some horrendous edges )

I love DIAMOND ... There not expensive . but is there any for he Lansky ? ( Havent seen any )
So maybe if the edge is like really FUBAR , you need to put down a new bevel first .

Could even be done free style ... EZE-LAP diamond hone & stone .. Did it this way for a long time ..
Put down a new bevel , then use the Lansky to take it all the way . ( What ever that is )
If you angle is off , just free style it closer . ( That learning / developing / a skill thing )
I use a jewellers eye piece so as to avoid removing too much metal . Check often and be happy .
The better you get at it the less time it takes .
But yeah , number one trick is the marker pen . Shows you where you are removing metal from and where you should be taking it from and where not !
Lansky is great , but not for putting down a new bevel or restoring a badly damaged one .
Seriously time consuming ! Ur probably better off paying some one $10 to put a new bevel on the knife rather than spending hours trying to clean up some ones erroneous ways with the Lansky .

The Lansky is brilliant in it's simplicity and it's ability to maintain a edge and keep an edge in good condition . A knife maintained on a Lansky should last a very long time , as a well maintained edge needs very little work to keep sharp .

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2021 6:30 am
by royal0014
Yes, Lansky does have diamond stones. The set comes with coarse, medium and fine stones. They also have an extra-coarse diamond, which I use if a new bevel is needed.
At the other end of the spectrum is the "sapphire" stone, which I'm pretty sure is actually ceramic.
Use it for a super final polish ....
Heck, Lansky even has a leather strop!

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2021 11:22 am
by old4570
At the other end of the spectrum is the "sapphire" stone, which I'm pretty sure is actually ceramic.
Use it for a super final polish ....
Heck, Lansky even has a leather strop!

Seen those ! ::tu::

If there is a diamond option , then certainly worth while to speed up work on those tougher edges ( needing more work ) .
Ceramic - I like ceramic sharpeners as well . Though sometimes they can be the worst option and at other times the best option . ( That double edged sword thing )

Re: How about a (sticky) thread for tips on using the Lansky ?

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2022 11:53 pm
by cudgee
For those Lansky users out there who happen to read this, thought you may be interested The Knife Connection has Lanksy products on sale at the moment. So if you need some replacement things or wish to upgrade might be worth a look. ::tu::