Mystery Knife Game

[New_Windsor_NY]

Ulster

No, not Ulster.

Camillus Cutlery Co.

No, not Camillus.

[New_Windsor_NY]

Two more pictures.
Both surviving blades have
the same 3-line tang stamp.
Click on a picture to ENLARGE.

[Ridgegrass]

Wilbert

[New_Windsor_NY]

Wilbert

No, not Wilbert.

[New_Windsor_NY]

Clue:
Knife Manufacturer.
Per GOINS, existed 22+ years.

Another picture for you.
Click to ENLARGE.

[Ridgegrass]

Winchester 1919-1942. J.O'.

[New_Windsor_NY]

Winchester 1919-1942. J.O'.

No, not Winchester.

[Ridgegrass]

Crucible

[New_Windsor_NY]

Crucible

No, not Crucible.

[New_Windsor_NY]

Another clue and another picture.
CLUE:
East of the Mississippi River.
NOT from Connecticut, Rhode Island or Pennsylvania.

[Ridgegrass]

Warwick

[New_Windsor_NY]

Warwick

Yes, WARWICK.
Congratulations, it's your turn.

1907 (maybe earlier) to 1929.

WARWICK
KNIFE CO.
NEW YORK

Both surviving "full" blades have the same tang stamp.
I couldn't quite catch the right angle to photograph the tang stamps (picture #1).
The tang stamps are more legible in the seller's picture (picture #2).

[Ridgegrass]

Skip: I pulled that one out of the blue! Wild guess from the bolsters.

Here's one from a short-lived maker. Spear, punch, cap, and can. Bale's missing . J.O'.

[danno50]

Challenge Cutlery Co Bridgeport

[Ridgegrass]

Not Challenge. Danno

[danno50]

Crucible Knife Co.

[Ridgegrass]

C'mon, What's your secret ? Are you hacking me! Crucible it is,
I was going to say there is a question whether Crucible was really a maker or just WT Grant's label made elsewhere. All the research I've done is inconclusive. Price and Levine say manufacturer in Lynn, Mass. but that's also where Grant's first store opened. I've also heard they were made by Utica and they do bear a resemblance. If anyone has any definitive info I'd like to hear it. I have 2 Crucible knives..
Anyway, I like this thread as is probably obvious.

Let's have another one J.O'.

[peanut740]

The Crucible scouts I've had appeared to be made by Utica.

[danno50]

C'mon, What's your secret ? Are you hacking me! Crucible it is,
I was going to say there is a question whether Crucible was really a maker or just WT Grant's label made elsewhere. All the research I've done is inconclusive. Price and Levine say manufacturer in Lynn, Mass. but that's also where Grant's first store opened. I've also heard they were made by Utica and they do bear a resemblance. If anyone has any definitive info I'd like to hear it. I have 2 Crucible knives..
Anyway, I like this thread as is probably obvious.

Let's have another one J.O'.

Nope, no hacking, I don't have the computer skills to hack anything. I look through applicable threads on here and BF to find knives with similar features: shields, bolsters, blade pulls etc.
I will have to wait for daylight to take a picture to post.

[Ridgegrass]

Thanks Peanut.

Danno, you're just too good at this. J.O'.

[danno50]

I do spend quite a bit of time on some of these, I consider it a learning experience. I also make a lot of use of Goins and LGIV. You do pretty well yourself, J.O'.

Next one. American, fairly old.

[Ridgegrass]

Schatt & Morgan

[danno50]

Schatt & Morgan

Sorry J.O'., Not Schatt & Morgan

[Ridgegrass]

Queen City

[danno50]

Queen City

Not Queen City, but you are in the right state. Manufacturer. This particular stamp was was around for 15 years.