Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Colonial Knife was incorporated in 1926 by three brothers; Antonio, Domenic, & Fredrick Paolantonio. It grew to become one of the largest pocket knife manufacturers in the US during the 1960s. The company shut down in 1998, but was back into production under the Colonial Cutlery International Corporation in 2001. Colonial Cutlery International, Inc. brand is the imported line of knives and tools while the U.S.A.- made products fall under the Colonial Knife brand.
Post Reply
User avatar
Joe Dirt
Posts: 1747
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 4:10 pm
Location: N.C. USA

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Joe Dirt »

Check out this NOS mechanics knife that was just posted as a new topic, Bobby!

http://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/kni ... 87&t=39892

... Joe
I've got a camouflage knife, but I can't find it.......

..... cardboard addicted.....

"The old timer's concentrated on making knives; not keeping records!!" ~ Bonfire bob
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Very interesting Joe!! Very rare to say the least... :lol:

After looking at our old Heritage Trapper's and Colonial's (Camillus) Trappers, I believe ours was a large Trapper and Colonial's was a medium... ::nod::

Here's a bit of history for you folks...
This is one of our first BIG orders with Camillus Cutlery Company..even though Colonial backed out of thier comitment with us at Heritage and totally "boned" us, I was smarter than them and I had a SOLID back up plan!! ::sotb:: ::sotb::
I still can't believe that Colonial blanked, stamped, and finished 500 sets of three blade stockman parts, JUST to trash them for scrap!! UNBELIEVABLE!!!! ::dang:: ::dang::
Just for spite's sake..shame on them.. ::uc:: ::uc:: ::uc::

My backup plan worked...
Robert P. "HERITAGE CUTLER'S INC".. ::groove:: ::groove::
Attachments
CCF01052014_00000.jpg
User avatar
Joe Dirt
Posts: 1747
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 4:10 pm
Location: N.C. USA

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Joe Dirt »

Interesting stuff, Bobby!

First off) The yeller Camillus trapper measures only aprox 3 3/4"
while the S & W measures aprox 4 1/4".

Second) The cap bolsters on the Camillus measure 5/8" while the
the cap bolsters on the Smith & wesson are 3/4". The Smit & Wesson
is an allround a larger knife.

Third) Why didn't Camillus use the rivets/pins to hold the handle scale
on the knife at each end? It prolly would have prevented that big crack
at the center pin!

I will get into more detail when I do a pic comparison of the two knives.


You gotta be kidding... ::hmm:: Camillus trashed 500 stockman???
Well that also just makes me scratch my head. What made them do that?
(or did I just read that wrong)

Great for you showing that invoice, Bobby. ::tu::
Soooo much left to sort out and learn! Thanks man! ::handshake::

... Joe
I've got a camouflage knife, but I can't find it.......

..... cardboard addicted.....

"The old timer's concentrated on making knives; not keeping records!!" ~ Bonfire bob
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Joe K. my dear friend...you seem to get everything ass-backwards!! haha..
COLONIAL "Boned Us" on the order we placed with them as I was peacefully leaving Colonial in 1995-96... ::skeptic:: ::skeptic::

We had already incorporated Heritage and we were putting the factory together and my family was happy to get rid of me then!!! ::barf::
We made an offer for machinery AND a sizable part order with Colonial Knife...are you with me so far??? WAY before we placed an order for stockman parts with Colonial, I had formed a solid relationship with Mr. Michael Dillon. plant manager of Camillus Cutlery Company...
Still with me??? (dam son, read your book; that's why I sent you one!)..... ::sneaky::

When I dig the original contract we made with Colonial and 500 "Old Cutler" grade blades and all parts, I'll post it...they made the parts for us and re-negged on the contract!!!
We never paid them and they refuse to sell us the parts and dumped them in the garbage.
Are you getting the picture me friend!!??????? ::dang:: ::dang::

My own family screwed us out of sure spite!!!!
I expected this SO I sent Camillus the business and a check for almost 30 K....
Here's the proof! Our first of many sizable orders with Camillus Cutlery Company...
Robert A.Paolantonio, Heritage Cutler's....
Attachments
CCF01052014_00000.jpg
User avatar
Joe Dirt
Posts: 1747
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 4:10 pm
Location: N.C. USA

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Joe Dirt »

:oops: Oh man, I seem to have a permanent lingering brain damage, Bobby. ::tease:: ::dang::
YES, I read your book and I appreciate the copy you sent with all the hard work you put into it... also your
post right above mine. ::dang:: Please feel free to whack me over the head with the stick - I deserve it. ::smack::
What a brain fart on me... that one stunk. :oops:

Colonial trashed the 500 parts in spite...

So sorry I made you type that info for about the millionth time. ::mdm::
Can you find it in your big heart to forgive me?... oh please, oh please. :mrgreen:

(you can rest assured that sort of unnecessary thing won't happen again :roll: )

... Joe
I've got a camouflage knife, but I can't find it.......

..... cardboard addicted.....

"The old timer's concentrated on making knives; not keeping records!!" ~ Bonfire bob
TexasJack
Posts: 183
Joined: Tue Nov 05, 2013 8:46 pm
Location: Deep in the heart of...

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by TexasJack »

Bonfire bob wrote:Nice score Jack!!!
Between the stag and the Rosewood, maybe a 1,000 of each!
Here's one of the original ads...
Robert P.

These knives arrived today. ::groove::
After looking at them and close :shock: .
I have to say they are among the finest knives I own.
I am now on the search for the rosewood models.
The fit, finish,and overall quality is second to none.
You really made some fine knives!!!
I will post some pictures later.
Jack
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Thanks for the compliment Jack; keep looking for those missing pieces to the
RAP Cutler, 5 ***** Star series. (do those like stars?).. maybe me and Joe K can design some new ones!! LOL...you put me and KJ in the same tool room, we'll be building God know's what! ::hmm:: ::hmm::
Keep up the good work Jack and I applaud your love for your new found hobby; it just happens to be OUR favorite!!

Joe, I couldn't help but bust your beans!! ::super_happy::
I'm so glad your such a good sport and these attributes of yours are the same as my closest friends and will always be respected.... :D :D
More importantly pal is that folks don't misunderstand and think that Camillus did anything wrong; they DID NOT! It was Colonial that rear-ended us, or tied to!! ::woot:: ::woot::

Your package is on it's way! You should have enough rivets to fix or repair any Colonial and or any large Camillus grade pocket knife. Also some toys; what the hell... :mrgreen:
You'll see no heads on the Cam. pins; that's the way they assembled their knives...
Bobby.. ::smirk::
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Hey folks, just so you know.... ::uc::

My private message option here at AAPK is NOT working!! ANY messages sent as private message turns up to "Unknown folder"..!!???? anybody have any clue?? ::shrug::

Anyway, Miller Bros. please contact my e-mail directly : bonfirebob11@cox.net
Thanks people.. RAP..... :|
User avatar
Miller Bro's
Gold Tier
Gold Tier
Posts: 12752
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2009 11:22 pm
Location: Earth

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Miller Bro's »

E-mail sent ::tu::
AAPK Janitor
369
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Hello Miller Bros; Wed. afternoon and no message yet!! ::shrug:: ::shrug::
Just in case : bonfirebob11@cox.net
Bob P...
User avatar
Miller Bro's
Gold Tier
Gold Tier
Posts: 12752
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2009 11:22 pm
Location: Earth

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Miller Bro's »

Bob, sent it yesterday evening. Please check your SPAM folder, the subject line will read "Knives" that`s me ::tu::
AAPK Janitor
369
User avatar
TripleF
Silver Tier
Silver Tier
Posts: 19257
Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2011 3:42 pm
Location: West Central FL
Contact:

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by TripleF »

Got this jack in a LOT purchase the other day.....
Attachments
lot1.9.14 057.JPG
SCOTT
HOME OF THE BRAVE! (not the scarety cats)
https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/catalog/triplef
Colonial Knife Company History ebook:
https://gumroad.com/l/ZLDb
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Yup! Nice two blade jack; # 4602 to be exact !! Although this was one of those styles that we made in so many ways with so many different handles. This little shell baby is probably late 60's production. In the 80's it was eventually changed to a # 44...This one tells it's age because of the short plump shield where as the newer version's had the long concave shield with the bowtie ends. Colonial used that long style on several knives up to 1998. :: ::hmm:: ::hmm:: hmm:: Rob P. CKCo..
User avatar
Joe Dirt
Posts: 1747
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 4:10 pm
Location: N.C. USA

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Joe Dirt »

Good eye on the "USA" marked Colonial, Scott! ::tu:: The more ya play with them the easier it gets to identify um!

... Joe
I've got a camouflage knife, but I can't find it.......

..... cardboard addicted.....

"The old timer's concentrated on making knives; not keeping records!!" ~ Bonfire bob
User avatar
Joe Dirt
Posts: 1747
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 4:10 pm
Location: N.C. USA

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Joe Dirt »

O.K. here is the comparison of the Camillus made Colonial Old Cutler and
the Heritage made Smith & Wesson.

To sum it up quickly - there is NO comparison! Only thing to point out is that
the Camillus made knife has half stops and the S&W doesn't. The pics will do the talking...

... Joe
Attachments
Trapper  - Heritage S&W top - Cam Old Cutler bottom  1.JPG
Trapper lengths - Heritage S&W top - Cam Old Cutler bottom  2.JPG
S & W Stag Trapper  3.jpg
Trappers - Stag  4.JPG
Trappers - Camillus half stop - S&W = no half stop  6.JPG
Trappers spey  7.JPG
Trappers skinner  8.JPG
I've got a camouflage knife, but I can't find it.......

..... cardboard addicted.....

"The old timer's concentrated on making knives; not keeping records!!" ~ Bonfire bob
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Very nice Joe..thanks for comparison photo's...
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Just so the gang here are all aware that this stag handle knife was made by me at
Heritage Cutler's! This was our first order, private labled for Mr. Stewart Taylor, Taylor Cutlery, a good old friend of mine! ::handshake::
5,000 2-blade, stamped for Smith and Wesson and it had hollow ground stainless steel blades, India stag and solid NS bolster and NS solid pin construction...

We eventually went with stainless steel solid pins for added strength and no pin movement as you might find on NS pin and bolster's. After opening and closing several times, you will see the ring in the bolster, were the pin is. We made all of our knives this way for Heritage.
Large stockman, large Trapper, a Barlow, small stockman, and a small lock-back. ::nod::
Robert P. Heritage Cutler's.... ::super_happy:: ::super_happy::
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

========================== ATTENTION =============================

After speaking with Arthur Green and Larry Clifford from the NCCA, The Northeast Cutlery Collectors Association, I will be attending and setting up a booth at the Mystic, CT show.

It's the "NCCA 32nd, Annual Extravaganza Knife Show" !! ::ds:: ::ds:: ::ds::
The show is Saturday, May 3rd from 9-5 pm and Sunday, May 4th from 9-3 pm at the
Mystic Hilton, Mystic Conn. (860) 572-0731.

This will be the first show I've attended in over 10 years and I'll be selling my books and three different styles of Antique knife skeletons similar to the ones I give with my book.

I will be showing a large amount of my personal knife collection consisting of lots of pearls, Mammoth Ivory's, and old Colonials, RAP Cutlers and Heritage knives!! ::groove:: ::groove::
Here is a reminder of my award winning day in August, 1997, for Best Factory Customized" knives! I'm there on the cover, bottom left, of the NCCA's newsletter, "The Northeast Edge"...
I hope to see some of you folks there... ::tu:: ::tu::
Robert Paolantonio, Colonial, RAP, and Heritage.... ::handshake::
Attachments
CCF01052014_00000.jpg
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

And this was my prize; a custom engraved CASE!!!
Attachments
CCF01062014_00000.jpg
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Just a reminder folks....

Please visit Mr. Scott Rauber's e-bay listings on his exceptional blog!! ::groove::

See : http://www.pocketknivesblog.com His professional and informative blog is one of the best sites to buy knives and more importantly, Scott is the "Exclusive" seller of my knife collection and he is an ACE at marketing and advertising; his site proves it!! ::nod:: ::nod::

Scott and I have also designed our "BIY", Build it yourself Barlow knife kits!!
We have sold many kits in the last six months and quantity's are limited now.. :shock:

Our kits come with all the parts to build your own self-customized Barlow pocket knife!!
The only thing not included is the handle material that you may personally choose to apply.
Two bone slabs, or stag, wood, any possible material that you want! ::shrug::

The kits come with two blades, (master blade stamped "Old Cutler"), two solid brass liners, one solid brass center scale, two springs and a multitude of possible assembly rivets and nails....These kits come with either plain or stamped Barlow bolster's and for a few bucks more, "Hand Engraved" bolster's! ::woot:: ::woot::

My kits come with a very detailed instruction manual and fully illustrated assembly pics.
Here are a few pages from the kits..DON'T WAIT!! These kits will not last much longer!

Robert Paolantonio, "Vintage" Colonial Old Cutler Barlow kits.
Attachments
CCF01152014_00000.jpg
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Here are some pics from the directions..
Attachments
CCF10082013_00002.jpg
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

And one more..
Attachments
CCF10082013_00004.jpg
User avatar
Joe Dirt
Posts: 1747
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 4:10 pm
Location: N.C. USA

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Joe Dirt »

Great Case Wharncliffe prize, Mr. custom R.A.P.!!!

Glad you decided to attend the NAAC show again too.
(Last time - 10 years ago! That's tooooo long).

Pretty neat drawings of the Old Cutler assembly. ::tu::
Did you take a course in technical drawing?

... Joe
I've got a camouflage knife, but I can't find it.......

..... cardboard addicted.....

"The old timer's concentrated on making knives; not keeping records!!" ~ Bonfire bob
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

Thank you my friend for the compliment...
No I never took an art class before but I always loved to draw when I was a kid and
I've handled these parts for so many years, I could draw them in my sleep!!
I have a pic or two that I'd like everyone to see..
R.P.CKCo...
Bonfire bob
Posts: 527
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2012 4:10 pm

Re: Now we have a Colonial thread,Show'em

Post by Bonfire bob »

This is what happens when you send an old toolmaker/CNC Machinest some parts and this is the outcome of those parts! This guy is the real deal!! Self taught cutler and 25 years ago, I would have hired him on the spot for his ability's alone and he would have had his own work bench right next to me in the assembly room at Colonial Knife Company!! ::super_happy::
That's not to mention his personallity and enthusiasm for the art of knife making.. ::tu::

Mr. Joe Keating, "ROYAL PINES CUTLERY" is an outstanding gentleman and a well versed cutler, in my opinion!! ::ds:: ::ds::
I thank God for his friendship every day. ::pray:: ::pray::

Here's to you Joe, I'm glad I met you!! ::tu:: ::tu::
Attachments
Bosley and bread photo's 308.jpg
Post Reply

Return to “Colonial Knife Collector's Forum”