Dishonest AAPK store

[edge213]

There is a listing in an AAPK store with this headline "Never Used Chris Reeve Large Sebenza 25 Knife with Box, Papers and Sheath. This is a copy."
Earlier in the day it said "This is a clone" at the end.
This is not a "copy" or "clone". It is an outright COUNTERFEIT meant to deceive someone. It even comes with paperwork with Chris Reeve Knives address, phone number and email. Idaho Made on the handles.
The box says "Proudly made in the USA. (which I highly doubt).
This extremely dishonest and should not be allowed in AAPK Stores.
I wonder what Chris Reeve Knives would think of this listing. Can anyone say "lawsuit"?

Comments welcome.

[Bryan]

Knives such as this are against AAPK policy. It has been taken out of inventory & we will be in contact with seller asap to explain said policy.

Appreciate the heads up

[Railsplitter]

Knives such as this are against AAPK policy. It has been taken out of inventory & we will be in contact with seller asap to explain said policy.

Appreciate the heads up

Excellent! I saw the Sold Out tab and thought somebody bought it. Glad that is not the case.

[btrwtr]

Thanks for taking care of this Bryan.

[KnifeSlinger#81]

Thank you Bryan.

[edge213]

Knives such as this are against AAPK policy. It has been taken out of inventory & we will be in contact with seller asap to explain said policy.

Appreciate the heads up

Thank you sir for taking care of this matter.
I know this kind of thing happens on eBay and at shows, but we need to keep it out of AAPK.

[Railsplitter]

Thank you Bryan and thank you David for addressing this. I agree that we don't need that kind of thing here and like Bryan said, it's against AAPK policy.

I'll give the seller the benefit of the doubt because his other offerings look rather attractive and reasonably priced for those interested in that kind of thing. No hard feelings here.

[just bob]

I don't say this in a rude or impolite way, but what is the AAPK policy? I'd like to read it. I had a Fighting Rooster KKK knife for sale on here and was asked to take it down. There have been others listed and sold on here. We have seen modern Nazi / Hitler knives sold on here and ebay doesn't allow that. Are they allowed on AAPK? I have seen Case knives with Delrin handles being sold as bone on here. I certainly don't say this in an accusatory way but we have one AAPK store that is run by a person whose Ebay knives seem to pop up quite often in the AAPK counterfeit forum. I'm not pointing a finger at anyone or saying anyone is doing anything wrong. I'd just like to read the policy. It is very hard to follow the rules when you don't know what the rules are. I appreciate the hard work Bryan puts in to keep things above board on here. The stores are a great asset to not only the sellers but also to the buyers.

[rea1eye]

Thanks Bryan for keeping a close watch on this forum and the AAPK stores !

Bob

[Bryan]

I don't say this in a rude or impolite way, but what is the AAPK policy? I'd like to read it. I had a Fighting Rooster KKK knife for sale on here and was asked to take it down. There have been others listed and sold on here. We have seen modern Nazi / Hitler knives sold on here and ebay doesn't allow that. Are they allowed on AAPK? I have seen Case knives with Delrin handles being sold as bone on here. I certainly don't say this in an accusatory way but we have one AAPK store that is run by a person whose Ebay knives seem to pop up quite often in the AAPK counterfeit forum. I'm not pointing a finger at anyone or saying anyone is doing anything wrong. I'd just like to read the policy. It is very hard to follow the rules when you don't know what the rules are. I appreciate the hard work Bryan puts in to keep things above board on here. The stores are a great asset to not only the sellers but also to the buyers.

Here is the link to our current selling policies...
https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/ca ... g-policies

There's nothing at the moment to address the sale of KKK & or Nazi knives, but that likely needs to change. I really do not know the right direction to take on that & we may need to start a new discussion about whether AAPK should allow them or not.

Regarding delrin advertised as bone... I hope this is generally out of mistake.

When found, I believe seller should be notified with requirement to correct which I will do if I see them, or when pointed out by others. We probably need a better reporting method for such instances. I can work on that. In the mean time, please let me know when seen via PM, email admin@allaboutpocketknives.com

[eveled]

Thanks Bryan.

[wlf]

Thanks Bryan

[GSPTOPDOG]

If I may interject on this thought: " There's nothing at the moment to address the sale of KKK & or Nazi knives, but that likely needs to change. I really do not know the right direction to take on that & we may need to start a new discussion about whether AAPK should allow them or not".
I have a few thoughts as to why of course knives with certain offensive themes should be banned without any question nor debate.

As for banning certain knives for the sake of Political Correctness, I think this a definitely a step in the right direction. As a relatively new member I understand my opinion my be of limited vale. However, I can think of several examples of knives that now can be seen in their true form as objects that offend and may cause some members to feel unsafe. For example, I would think that many people are offended by the Confederate battle flag and its association of slavery and the oppression of peoples of color. Perhaps this would be a good place to start and would make many people in the public square feel much better with such a positive step to erasing this image from the past and cleaning up some unpleasant aspects of American history.

Also let us not forget the genocide inflicted on the Native American peoples from whom this country was unlawfully taken so many years ago. I would suggest that all knives with themes such as "Buffalo Bill Cody" or "Hop-Along Cassidy" and other "western themed knives" of this type be prohibited from sale. These are symbols of White European western expansion and the geocide of Native Peoples and should be banned without discussion.

I myself have been made very uncomfortable when observing that members on this site have posted knives for sale that feature the so called "Founding Fathers" etched on the blades or engraved on the scales. To promote a group of old, white, slave owning, racists and misogynist men must upset a great number of members who do not benefit for a system of White Privilege and Male dominance that has oppressed women and minorities for hundreds of years. I would think that banning all items with "Founding Fathers" themes would be in the greater public interest.

There are many other categories to address, however I will leave that up to other more seasoned members of the forum. Please remember; "If it offends ONE person, we should ALL be offended".

[Mr. Chips]

If I may interject on this thought: " There's nothing at the moment to address the sale of KKK & or Nazi knives, but that likely needs to change. I really do not know the right direction to take on that & we may need to start a new discussion about whether AAPK should allow them or not".
I have a few thoughts as to why of course knives with certain offensive themes should be banned without any question nor debate.

As for banning certain knives for the sake of Political Correctness, I think this a definitely a step in the right direction. As a relatively new member I understand my opinion my be of limited vale. However, I can think of several examples of knives that now can be seen in their true form as objects that offend and may cause some members to feel unsafe. For example, I would think that many people are offended by the Confederate battle flag and its association of slavery and the oppression of peoples of color. Perhaps this would be a good place to start and would make many people in the public square feel much better with such a positive step to erasing this image from the past and cleaning up some unpleasant aspects of American history.

Also let us not forget the genocide inflicted on the Native American peoples from whom this country was unlawfully taken so many years ago. I would suggest that all knives with themes such as "Buffalo Bill Cody" or "Hop-Along Cassidy" and other "western themed knives" of this type be prohibited from sale. These are symbols of White European western expansion and the geocide of Native Peoples and should be banned without discussion.

I myself have been made very uncomfortable when observing that members on this site have posted knives for sale that feature the so called "Founding Fathers" etched on the blades or engraved on the scales. To promote a group of old, white, slave owning, racists and misogynist men must upset a great number of members who do not benefit for a system of White Privilege and Male dominance that has oppressed women and minorities for hundreds of years. I would think that banning all items with "Founding Fathers" themes would be in the greater public interest.

There are many other categories to address, however I will leave that up to other more seasoned members of the forum. Please remember; "If it offends ONE person, we should ALL be offended".

Please tell me that you are kidding, because most of the above is utter nonsense.

[djknife13]

GSPTOPDOG, You just offended me by nearly everything you said. Some people are offended by the fact that we own and value knives. I'm proud of our history as a country and the men and women that fought and suffered to make it a great nation. They deserve our gratitude, not our condemnation for not being perfect.____Dave

[bestgear]

I would think that many people are offended by the Confederate battle flag and its association of slavery and the oppression of peoples of color.

Also let us not forget the genocide inflicted on the Native American peoples from whom this country was unlawfully taken so many years ago.

These are symbols of White European western expansion and the geocide of Native Peoples and should be banned without discussion.

To promote a group of old, white, slave owning, racists and misogynist men must upset a great number of members who do not benefit for a system of White Privilege and Male dominance that has oppressed women and minorities for hundreds of years.

Please remember; "If it offends ONE person, we should ALL be offended".

If what you write is your true sentiment, how do you reconcile your post from Tuesday Dec 10, 2019 at 9:26 pm regarding your use of Chinese knives where you say:

“I usually carry a Case trapper, a Leatherman PST (USA made only!) and for the dirty work a Gonzo brand Chinese copy of a Lion's Steel knife. I also will carry a real Lion's Steel folding knife, I just don't have that knife on today. I don't mind abusing the Chinese copy, I think it was $20. I think my real Lion's Steel folding knife was $200!”

Do you know how people are treated in China?

The problem with practicing what you preach, or maintaining a high moral standard, is it’s work. You tell people you care about oppression of peoples, genocide, symbols of White European western expansion and the oppression of women and minorities for hundreds of years, this means you have to do these things too.

But what if you just said you do these things, but didn’t? You get all the benefits of people thinking you’re a good and capable person, but you don’t have to practice any restraint. It’s win-win.

What say you? And what about your eBay auction: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Lot-of-3-BUDDH ... 4164238286 for 3 Chinese Buddha’s?

[Dinadan]

snip
I can think of several examples of knives that now can be seen in their true form as objects that offend and may cause some members to feel unsafe.
snip

I am going to give you the benefit of doubt and assume you are using irony to discredit political correctness. If you are sincere in your remarks ... I do not want to annoy Bryan or his moderators by saying what I think about you.

Bryan: thank you for making this such a fine place.

[treefarmer]

Well, well, well, bite my tongue! Pretty soon I wont be able to mention that we drive Fords in our family since I believe there is probably some dirt someone can dig up on Henry Ford. It would be a shame to hurt some one's feeling because they are offended by FoMoCo.

Treefarmer

[Bryan]

As for banning certain knives for the sake of Political Correctness, I think this a definitely a step in the right direction. As a relatively new member I understand my opinion my be of limited vale. However, I can think of several examples of knives that now can be seen in their true form as objects that offend and may cause some members to feel unsafe. For example, I would think that many people are offended by the Confederate battle flag and its association of slavery and the oppression of peoples of color. Perhaps this would be a good place to start and would make many people in the public square feel much better with such a positive step to erasing this image from the past and cleaning up some unpleasant aspects of American history.

Also let us not forget the genocide inflicted on the Native American peoples from whom this country was unlawfully taken so many years ago. I would suggest that all knives with themes such as "Buffalo Bill Cody" or "Hop-Along Cassidy" and other "western themed knives" of this type be prohibited from sale. These are symbols of White European western expansion and the geocide of Native Peoples and should be banned without discussion.

I myself have been made very uncomfortable when observing that members on this site have posted knives for sale that feature the so called "Founding Fathers" etched on the blades or engraved on the scales. To promote a group of old, white, slave owning, racists and misogynist men must upset a great number of members who do not benefit for a system of White Privilege and Male dominance that has oppressed women and minorities for hundreds of years. I would think that banning all items with "Founding Fathers" themes would be in the greater public interest.

There are many other categories to address, however I will leave that up to other more seasoned members of the forum. Please remember; "If it offends ONE person, we should ALL be offended".

I don't know if it was your intent, but some of what you say in this post further solidifies my belief that banning things for the sake of political correctness is absurd.

If not your intent, I have a serious question or two. Perhaps you can change my mind. If so, well played

[Sharpnshinyknives]

If I may interject on this thought: " There's nothing at the moment to address the sale of KKK & or Nazi knives, but that likely needs to change. I really do not know the right direction to take on that & we may need to start a new discussion about whether AAPK should allow them or not".
I have a few thoughts as to why of course knives with certain offensive themes should be banned without any question nor debate.

As for banning certain knives for the sake of Political Correctness, I think this a definitely a step in the right direction. As a relatively new member I understand my opinion my be of limited vale. However, I can think of several examples of knives that now can be seen in their true form as objects that offend and may cause some members to feel unsafe. For example, I would think that many people are offended by the Confederate battle flag and its association of slavery and the oppression of peoples of color. Perhaps this would be a good place to start and would make many people in the public square feel much better with such a positive step to erasing this image from the past and cleaning up some unpleasant aspects of American history.

Also let us not forget the genocide inflicted on the Native American peoples from whom this country was unlawfully taken so many years ago. I would suggest that all knives with themes such as "Buffalo Bill Cody" or "Hop-Along Cassidy" and other "western themed knives" of this type be prohibited from sale. These are symbols of White European western expansion and the geocide of Native Peoples and should be banned without discussion.

I myself have been made very uncomfortable when observing that members on this site have posted knives for sale that feature the so called "Founding Fathers" etched on the blades or engraved on the scales. To promote a group of old, white, slave owning, racists and misogynist men must upset a great number of members who do not benefit for a system of White Privilege and Male dominance that has oppressed women and minorities for hundreds of years. I would think that banning all items with "Founding Fathers" themes would be in the greater public interest.

There are many other categories to address, however I will leave that up to other more seasoned members of the forum. Please remember; "If it offends ONE person, we should ALL be offended".

While I understand banning KKK and Nazi related. I think the idea of banning the founding fathers is absolutely the dumbest thing we could ever do. You cannot constantly be cowering before the PC crowd, they are constantly coming up with new things to be offended and angry over, so what’s the point in trying to keep up with the offense of the “month”. And you can stop pushing that “white Privilege “ “male dominance “ garbage on here. Most of us aren’t apologizing for anything that has to do with the home, skin and socio-economic level we were born into. Save yourself some time and deep six that crap right now.
No I don’t agree with your last line “ if it offends one we should all be offended.” Don’t get me started on what’s wrong with the logic of all that, cause there is a lot wrong with that statement.

[dlr110]

I haven’t read everything in this thread, but I feel like I need to add my two cents worth. I don’t give a damn about the KKK & Nazis knives, I don’t have them, and I don’t want them, personally they are disgusting. What I do care about is infringing on someone else’s liberty’s and their right to sell them or someone to buy them. Banning something like this just for the sake of banning them in order to protect someone’s feelings is wrong. I see those knives all the time in antique stores, flea markets and online and I just keep on moving, that’s my right and my choice.

In this case we’re taking something away, something that is real, something that is a part of history. Ask yourself should we ban all weapons used by Japanese forces or any other axis powers of WWII? Don’t you believe the atrocities by other forces were just as evil, but I don’t hear a cry to ban them. Why are we trying to erase a period in our own country’s history by taking down statues, plaques and buildings that remind us about the Civil War south, but not the north. No matter if your talking about a Nazis knife that was actually from WWII or a statue of Stonewall Jackson, to ban either one because someone’s feelings are hurt or for the sake of the modern day evil of “political correctness” is an injustice to our history and an insult to the intelligence of every rational thinking person.

Having said all of that, this is a private website with rules and conditions that have to be followed. But if we decided to ban these and any other similar items I will feel like we have lost something as a people, and as a respected source of information by everyone.

I don’t feel I have expressed myself very well on this matter, but I hope you understand the point I was trying to get across.

David Roberts

[GSPTOPDOG]

I will ask this to those that want to ban "Nazi" marked items because they offend some people, what about the 20 million dead inside the Soviet Union that were victims of the Stalin regime and the USSR government? Can I not own a Mosin-Nagant bayonet now? Or a bayonet for an AK-47? We can start with a knife with a marking of the KKK and a swastika on a knife blade and then where do go from there? In December of 1937, the Japanese Imperial Army marched into China's capital city of Nanking and proceeded to murder 300,000 out of 600,000 civilians and soldiers in the city. Perhaps AAPK should ban all katanas and tanto blades? Do we not offend Elizabeth Warren and her followers by offering a Kit Carson commemorative knife or Andrew Jackson limited edition folder? The real question is where will it end? First they came for the KKK knives and I did not speak out because I did not own a KKK knife,..

[Mumbleypeg]

I will ask this to those that want to ban "Nazi" marked items because they offend some people, what about the 20 million dead inside the Soviet Union that were victims of the Stalin regime and the USSR government? Can I not own a Mosin-Nagant bayonet now? Or a bayonet for an AK-47? We can start with a knife with a marking of the KKK and a swastika on a knife blade and then where do go from there? In December of 1937, the Japanese Imperial Army marched into China's capital city of Nanking and proceeded to murder 300,000 out of 600,000 civilians and soldiers in the city. Perhaps AAPK should ban all katanas and tanto blades? Do we not offend Elizabeth Warren and her followers by offering a Kit Carson commemorative knife or Andrew Jackson limited edition folder? The real question is where will it end? First they came for the KKK knives and I did not speak out because I did not own a KKK knife,..

So from this I take it your previous post was sarcasm, intended to show the absurdity of trying to “police” items offered for sale in AAPK stores based on some ones (or anyone’s) notion of political correctness. If so you did a good job - your comments in that earlier post are absurd. And I agree, the notion is absurd. There is no “right” to not be offended.

Ken

[doglegg]

I'm a little surprised at the turn made from the original discussion. The OP pointed out a counterfeit knife. The discussion has gone to politically offensive knives. I enjoy silver coins. I avoid counterfeit coins. I do not avoid silver coinage just because I don't like the time period or history of the country they come from. Two totally different discussions. Jmho.

[Mumbleypeg]

I originally said something in my post about being offended by counterfeits. However I removed it before submitting the post.

I think the conversation turned with Bryan’s comment

There's nothing at the moment to address the sale of KKK & or Nazi knives, but that likely needs to change. I really do not know the right direction to take on that & we may need to start a new discussion about whether AAPK should allow them or not.

Instead of starting a new discussion it just took off from there, in this same thread.



Ken