Three Eafengrow Knives

A place to discuss & share pictures of knives made in China.
Post Reply
pitonyak
Posts: 45
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2023 2:11 pm
Location: Ohio, USA
Contact:

Three Eafengrow Knives

Post by pitonyak »

I first noticed Eafengrow knives when I saw that they sold a few knives in D2 for affordable prices. I purchased one and liked it much more than I thought so I purchased a few more. I often research companies when they make a knife I like and finding information has been much more difficult than normal for me (in my opinion).

Eafengrow is owned by Shenzhen Yifeng International Trading Company. Eafengrow is also shown as Eafen Grow.

Eafengrow has a good reputation based on build quality (strong qualifier there), but, they order their knives from OEMs and do not build them. They have a history of knives with the wrong steel. I looked at some test results and

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... rm=enabled

Six knives tested after 2019 had the stated steel five D2 and one14C28N. Five knives tested in 2019 all stated D2 steel but they instead had steel such as 5CR15MOV, 8CR13MOV, 8CR14MOV, or 440. Eafengrow claimed the problem was the suppliers and they said that they would fix the problem. Off hand, it looks like they did.

If I like a specific knife and then buy another, if they changed suppliers, everything about the quality and steel may be different. At least with a company like Buck, there is a possibility that they will test the knife. Then again, the Chinese made Buck knives use 420J2. But, back to the Eafengrow knives that I own.

I have purchased five or six Eafengrow knives over the years and it boils down to three specific knives all with D2 steel. I measured the sharpening angle as provided by the factory using my goniometer.

For sharpening, I used the Work Sharp WSSAKO81112 Blade Grinder Attachment for Ken Onion Edition Knife and Tool Sharpener. For these blades this is perfect and I can use 1" wide belts. The other two use narrower belts that I might prefer for smaller knives or knives that are concave. The D2 blades were much tougher to wear down than some of my more standard steel blades. I have not had to profile any of my newer steel knives such as S35VN, S45VN, or CPM-S110V because they came sharp and have not required more than maintenance sharpening. I have done a bunch on 420HC and easier steels.

I then finished with the Spyderco Tri-Angle Premium Sharpmaker using their standard Medium and Fine ceramic rods. Although I do own the ultra-fine rods, I did not use them for these knives.


Eafengrow EF11


The EF11 which sells for roughly $12 has a 2.8" D2 blade. The handle is Red Wood, which might just mean that it is stained “redish” in color. The weight is 3.42 oz.
Eafengrow_EF11_dual_photo.jpg
The knife Opens and closes trivially, but, you need to keep your hands in the right place so that the blade does not close. The knife is pretty beefy even if it is not terribly long. The wood scales are over a steel liner. I strongly prefer a locking knife and nothing holds the blade open apart from your hand with the part that sticks out the back of the knife when it is closed. The knife is, however, very comfortable in my hand.

The first EF11 I bought a few years ago came very sharp so I never sharpened it before I gave it away. The second (recently purchased) was not as sharp and I measured the factory edge to be about 25° per side. I used the Worksharp to take the primary angle under 15°. I then polished the edge past a 5K belt finishing with a power strop. The knife was very sharp, but, I did this freehand and I finished on the Spyderco where it is easy to do a final touch-up at 15° for my secondary bevel.

When finished, the edge was very polished and nice looking. I cut thin newsprint very nicely as I cut wavy patterns into the paper.

While belt sharpening at finer grits, I drew a thin paper-like burr along the entire edge that kept it from cutting paper well until after I removed the burr. I removed the burr by either running the cutting edge gently in a piece of wood or by “stropping” the blade on one of my ceramic stones. I expect that simply using the Spyderco would have also removed the burr.

A very impressive edge on finishing.


Eafengrow EF76


The Eafengrow EF76 has G10 handles that come in black (the one I have), Jade (light green), and Orange. All three have a D2 Stone-washed Blade and a deep carry pocket clip. The cost is roughly $25, but it was $20 after a 20% instant coupon on Amazon.

Eafengrow_EF76_dual_photo.jpg

The knife Opens easily and has a frame lock. There is no spring assist with the knife but I can open it without too much trouble if I flick my wrist. Most of my other knives open a bit more easily than this (Case and Buck with a similar opening mechanism).

This knife does not have a liner, but at the bottom rear there is a chunk of metal that adds some heft to the knife. The knife is sanded smooth (very little texture), and it feels good in the hand, but, without texture I expect it to be slippery (ish) when wet.

The D2 blade is 3.5" long and weighs 4.34 oz, so almost the same weight as the EF11.

Bevel angle was similar to the EF11 so I did the same for sharpening with exactly the same results.


Eafengrow EF223


The Eafengrow EF223 has G10 handles that come in orange, brown, and black. All three have a D2 Blade and a deep carry pocket clip. Notice that the black knife has a darker blade than the orange and the brown handled knives. These sell for $20 on Amazon.

Eafengrow_EF223_dual_photo.jpg

The knife Opens easily and has a frame lock. There is no spring assist with the knife but I can open it without too much trouble if I flick my wrist. Most of my other knives open a bit more easily than this (Case and Buck with a similar opening mechanism).

This knife has a steel liner, but it is still the lightest of the three knives by about half an ounce. The handle is textured and feels good in the hand.

The D2 blade is 3.5" long and weighs 3.84 oz, the lightest of the knives.

I have had a couple of these and I usually give them away to someone who needs a knife because they are one of the cheaper knives that I might carry. Every one of these knives came pretty sharp. I measured the factory edge at roughly 13.5° per side. I was happy with the edge until I sharpened my other two knives. I was not able to get it cutting as well as the other two, but, I only did a quick sharpen on my spyderco. I think that for fancy cutting I would want to polish the existing edge because the primary factory grind is rather rough compared to the polished surface that I created on the other two before I did the final sharpening. I just have not take the time to do it yet because the results are still pretty amazing for a minute or two of work. I currently have an orange knife and a brown one will be delivered shortly. I will probably polish those and then do a final sharpening. At the moment, however, I am very happy with the edge even though I expect do better with 10 minutes setup / take down and four or five minutes work per knife.
pitonyak
Posts: 45
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2023 2:11 pm
Location: Ohio, USA
Contact:

Re: Three Eafengrow Knives

Post by pitonyak »

I received three more EF223 knives this last weekend and they all had the same (ish) angle and sharpening. As with the others, I was able to cut curves in thin newsprint. The edge is consistent and clean along a secondary bevel.

I realized that each of these EF223 knives come with a small square of white cloth in the box.
User avatar
1967redrider
Gold Tier
Gold Tier
Posts: 17670
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2011 4:23 pm
Location: Alexandria, VA
Contact:

Re: Three Eafengrow Knives

Post by 1967redrider »

I have one of those 76's in Jade G-10. Haven't carried it hardly at all, not sure if it's D2 or something else. I picked it up when I was on a Jade G-10 kick a few years back.
Pocket, fixed, machete, axe, it's all good!

You're going to look awfully silly with that knife sticking out of your @#$. -Clint Eastwood, High Plains Drifter
pitonyak
Posts: 45
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2023 2:11 pm
Location: Ohio, USA
Contact:

Re: Three Eafengrow Knives

Post by pitonyak »

1967redrider wrote: Mon Aug 28, 2023 12:35 pm I have one of those 76's in Jade G-10. Haven't carried it hardly at all, not sure if it's D2 or something else. I picked it up when I was on a Jade G-10 kick a few years back.
There should be a D2 on the clip side of the blade. Do you remember if you decided to sharpen the blade, or just use it as it came from the factory?
User avatar
edge213
Gold Tier
Gold Tier
Posts: 8015
Joined: Sat Jan 25, 2014 12:48 am
Location: The Crossroads of America

Re: Three Eafengrow Knives

Post by edge213 »

No one should be surprised that the Chinese would lie about the steel in a knife.
The CCP isn't known for honesty.
When it comes to purchases from the Chinese......"buyer beware".
David
"Glowing like the metal on the edge of a knife" Meat Loaf
pitonyak
Posts: 45
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2023 2:11 pm
Location: Ohio, USA
Contact:

Re: Three Eafengrow Knives

Post by pitonyak »

edge213 wrote: Tue Aug 29, 2023 12:34 am No one should be surprised that the Chinese would lie about the steel in a knife.
The CCP isn't known for honesty.
When it comes to purchases from the Chinese......"buyer beware".
On a woodworking forum someone said something like "I would never purchase a table saw made in China" and someone commented that what really makes a difference is related to the quality control setup by the manufacturer to verify the specs. Saw Stop saw is considered a very good saw and they have people on site in China to over-see the process (or so it was stated).

My largest concern with Eafengrow is that it looks like they find external suppliers that handle the entire process and Eafengrow probably has little
(or maybe no) ability to verify the results; and Eafengrow probably is not paying an external group to do it for them. So, as you say, buyer beware.

According to the spreadsheet here:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... rm=enabled

Line 159 claims that the Buck knife tested was below claimed Rockwell hardness. The steel was S30V and the model number indicates USA made. At least with Buck, I know for certain that they will warrant the knife, even one made in China. Although I do have a stash of Buck knives made in China, I have far more made in the USA.

Not related, but are all CIVIVI knives made in China? I understand that they often have a premium version and a not premium version of knives. I own one and it is (I think) not premium. I believe that the steel is Nitro-V, and I have no idea how good or bad that would be. Some people tell me that it is close to S35VN, some say S35VN is better. I bought the knife because I did not own a CIVIVI and I liked the knife.

All that said, I have had probably ten Eafengrow knives and the build quality seemed solid on all of them. I have found the sharpening job very nice on all of the EF223 versions, which includes not only the edge, but also the supplied angle.
Post Reply

Return to “Chinese-made knives”